Alltrust was founded on the premise that people and customer service should be the driving focus of any successful employee benefits program. So it started with two employees, a one-desk office and nothing more than a thermal fax machine in downtown Tarpon Springs, Florida.
Joe founded Alltrust in 1994 with an ‘off the wall’ idea to provide unparalleled value and create a company focus entirely on employee benefits. Coming from a family of physicians and previously working for a large regional insurance agency; he understood that healthcare is not just an insurance product. It is a complex, but essential influence in our day to day
lives, a support system that, when used properly, can and should give people peace of mind in their most difficult and darkest times. As a result, he believed healthcare and health consumers should be given the same intimacy and support that a physician
would have with a patient. And, Alltrust Insurance was born.
Karen founded Alltrust with Joe Part in 1994; her background includes over 20 years in the financial consulting industry. As a 
previous owner of a financial consulting business, Karen has extended her knowledge of financial products; corporate finance, taxes, and structure; and in-depth knowledge of the public sector. Mrs. Brayboy wore many ‘hats’ and was very instrumental in becoming one of the largest and most successful benefits and human capital firms in Florida.
During this time, we continued to establish the Alltrust Insurance brand, focusing on our process and core values. And, in return, our book of business continued to thrive and our team continued to grow.
Alltrust Insurance moved to the current location in Palm Harbor, FL
• Ranked #3519 on Inc. 5000’s America’s Fastest Growing Private Companies
• Tampa Bay Business Journal Fast Fifty Company
• Tampa Bay Business Journal Best Places to Work for 2008
Joe Part had the opportunity to grace the cover of Employee Benefits Adviser and was featured in the cover story, “Drill Master Joe Part pushes advisors to better manage the prospect pipeline” in October 2008.
Top 500 Companies to Work for on Gulf Coast
• #3588 on Inc. 5000’s America’s Fastest Growing Private Companies
• Florida Trends Magazine Best Companies to Work for 2009
• Tampa Bay Business Journal Fast Fifty Company two years in a row
• Back to back winner of Tampa Bay Business Journal’s Best Places to Work for 2009
Alltrust made the Tampa Bay Business Journal’s Fast Fifty Company for the third time in a row
• #3870 on Inc. 5000’s America’s Fastest Growing Private Companies
• Florida Trends Magazine Best Companies to Work for 2010
• Tampa Bay Business Journal’s Best Places to Work for 2010
• Business Insurance, Best Places to Work 2011
• Landed a spot on the Florida Trends Magazine’s Best Companies to Work for 2011 for the third time
• Forth time winner of Tampa Bay Business Journal Best Places to Work for 2011
• Alltrust hits #4862 on Inc. 5000’s America’s Fastest Growing Private Companies
• Alltrust makes #4649 on Inc. 5000’s America’s Fastest Growing Private Companies
• Four time winner of Florida Trends Magazine Best Companies to Work For 2012
• Over 400 Florida-based Companies as Clients
Joe Part was featured in the Tampa Bay Business Journal article, “Joe Part: Local support will improve community” in January 2013
• Five years in a row for Florida Trends Magazine’s Best Companies to Work for 2013
Alltrust Insurance refocused their brand identity.
New mantra: We consider ourselves individual fingerprints, that when connected, create a strong helping hand for you organization. Whether you need a hand to guide you, support you, or cheer you on, we are who you need us to be. We have a relentless passion for everything that touches your human capital, a passion that that results in productivity, profitability, and execution. We may each have our own fingerprints, but together with you, we are “All In”.
• Business Insurance, Best Places to Work for 2014
• Florida Trends Magazine Best Companies to Work for 2014 six years in a row
• Fifth time winner of Tampa Bay Business Journal Best Places to Work for 2014
Alltrust was selected to join Acrisure – the fastest growing and now the fourth largest insurance agency in the United States.
Through this strategic partnership, our local practice has expanded its depth of expertise and scope of resources to offer the sophistication and counsel that our consulting clients would expect from a large national agency.
• Florida Trends Magazine Best Companies to Work for 2015 seventh year in year in a row-
• Sixth time winner of Tampa Bay Business Journal’s Best Places to Work for 2015
• Seven time placing as a Time Inc. 5000 And Honoree and ranked #4245 on Inc. 5000’s America’s Fastest Growing Private Companies
• Florida Trends Magazine Best Companies to Work for 2016 for a eighth time in a row
Tim Love Joins Alltrust as Chief Executive Officer with over 32 years of experience in the healthcare industry in leadership positions with firms such as HUB International, Humana, United Healthcare, Wells Fargo, and Lincoln Financial.
John Rutan was announced as Alltrust’s Executive Vice President of Client Experience
• Decade winning streak for Florida Trends Magazine’s Best Companies to Work for 2018
